Scanned or typed signature: is it valid?
The Docform team · Published November 13, 2026 · 7 min read

Key takeaways
Under French law, a scanned or typed signature does not make a contract void: most contracts are formed by the parties’ agreement alone. The difficulty is evidence. The Civil Code requires that the signatory can be identified and that the integrity of the document is guaranteed. A pasted image or a typed name establishes neither. If the signature is challenged, consent will have to be proven by other means.
What exactly are we talking about?
Three practices are often confused. They do not carry the same weight.
- A pasted signature image: a handwritten signature was scanned once, and its image is then inserted into a Word or PDF document.
- A typed name: the signatory types their name at the bottom of a document or an email, sometimes in a font that imitates handwriting.
- A scan of a hand-signed contract: the contract was printed, signed in ink, then scanned. A paper original exists.
The first two are signatures created without any identification process. The third is a copy of a document signed by hand. The rest of this article keeps these situations apart.
What does French law say about electronic documents and signatures?
Two articles of the French Civil Code set the framework.
Article 1366 gives an electronic document the same evidential weight as a paper document, on two conditions: that the person it comes from can be duly identified, and that it is drawn up and stored in conditions that guarantee its integrity.
Article 1367 defines the signature. It identifies its author and expresses their consent to the obligations arising from the document. When it is electronic, it consists of the use of a reliable identification process guaranteeing its link with the document to which it relates.
Two requirements therefore run through both provisions: identification of the signatory and integrity of the document. A scanned or typed signature has to be assessed against them.
Why do a pasted image or a typed name prove so little?
Both practices fall short of the two Civil Code requirements.
- Identification: a signature image can be copied from one document to another. Anyone who has ever received a signed document can reuse it. A typed name can be typed by anyone. Nothing ties the signature to the person.
- Link with the document: the image or the name is not attached to the content. The same image can be placed on a different text without leaving a trace.
- Integrity: a Word file or an unprotected PDF can be edited afterwards. Nothing shows that the text produced is the one that was accepted.
- Date: no reliable element establishes when the signature was made.
The eIDAS Regulation (EU No 910/2014) defines the electronic signature broadly: data in electronic form, attached to or logically associated with other data, which the signatory uses to sign. Its Article 25 prohibits denying a signature legal effect or admissibility solely because it is in electronic form or is not qualified.
Admissible does not mean conclusive. A court may examine a scanned signature; it is not bound to see in it proof that the named person consented.
What does each of the three eIDAS levels change?
The eIDAS Regulation distinguishes three levels of electronic signature. Each adds guarantees on identification and integrity.
- Simple signature: no particular technical requirement. Its value depends entirely on the surrounding evidence: signing journey, authentication, event log.
- Advanced signature: it meets the conditions of Article 26. It is uniquely linked to the signatory, is capable of identifying them, is created using data they keep under their sole control, and makes any subsequent change to the document detectable.
- Qualified signature: an advanced signature created with a qualified device and based on a qualified certificate. It has the legal effect of a handwritten signature. Under French law, it alone benefits from the presumption of reliability, until proven otherwise.
A pasted image or a typed name sits, at best, at the very bottom of this scale, without the evidence a signature service adds even at the simple level. We cover the highest level in our article on the qualified electronic signature, and the definition of the three levels in the eIDAS electronic signature glossary entry.
What happens if the signature is challenged?
As long as nobody objects, the form of the signature matters little. The difficulty arises when the other party denies having signed.
Article 1373 of the French Civil Code allows the party against whom a private document is relied upon to disown their handwriting or signature. The signature then has to be verified. For an electronic signature, the court examines whether the conditions of Articles 1366 and 1367 are met.
The burden of proof lies with the party relying on the contract. With a qualified signature, that party benefits from a presumption. Without one, it must establish the reliability of the process. With a pasted image or a typed name, there is no process to describe: proof of consent has to come from elsewhere.
- Correspondence: negotiation emails, the document being sent from the signatory’s address, acknowledgments of receipt.
- Performance: payments, deliveries, purchase orders, undisputed invoices.
- Prima facie written evidence: a document coming from the party who disputes the contract and making the claim plausible can be supplemented by other evidence.
The rules of evidence also depend on the parties. Written proof is required for acts above an amount set by decree, currently 1,500 euros, whereas between merchants commercial acts may be proven by any means. The outcome remains a matter for the court.
When is a scan enough in practice, and when is it not?
A scan of a hand-signed contract is a separate case. It is a copy. Article 1379 of the French Civil Code gives a reliable copy the same evidential weight as the original, reliability being left to the court’s assessment. As long as the paper original exists, it can be produced. Keep it.
For a pasted image or a typed name, the choice depends on the risk you are willing to accept.
- Where it may be enough: an internal document, an acknowledgment of receipt, a low-stakes approval with a known partner, when correspondence and performance already prove the agreement.
- Where it should not be enough: a contract with financial stakes or a long term, a commitment with a party you do not know, a document signed by a consumer or an employee, a guarantee or a surety.
- Where it cannot be enough: documents for which a law imposes a form or a signature level. The law sometimes requires a written document on pain of nullity, and some documents call for a qualified signature.
The useful test is the cost of a dispute over the very existence of the agreement, compared with that of an electronic signature with identification and an evidence file. A written internal rule, by contract type, avoids deciding case by case.
The question “who signed?” comes with another: did that person have authority to bind their company? We address it in our article on the contract signatory.
In Docform
Docform includes an e-signature compliant with the eIDAS framework, which replaces the pasted image or the PDF sent back by email. Invited signers authenticate with a one-time code sent by email before accessing the document. The steps of the signature are recorded in an evidence file, downloadable with the contract. As an option, a Certigna electronic seal is applied to the final PDF. Docform does not provide qualified signatures: this signature does not benefit from the presumption of reliability. The signed contract and its evidence file are stored in the contract repository. Details are on the electronic signature page.
Frequently asked questions
- Does a scanned signature have legal value?
- It does not make the contract void, but its evidential value is weak. A signature image does not reliably identify its author or guarantee its link with the document, which is what Article 1367 of the French Civil Code requires of an electronic signature.
- Is a typed signature valid?
- A typed name can express agreement, and it cannot be dismissed solely because it is electronic. It does not, however, prove who typed it. If it is challenged, consent will have to be established by other evidence.
- What is the difference between a scanned signature and an electronic signature?
- A scanned signature is an image. An electronic signature, within the meaning of the French Civil Code, is a reliable identification process that guarantees the link between the signature and the document. The former can be copied freely; the latter produces evidence.
- Is a contract signed by hand and then scanned valid?
- Yes. The contract was signed by hand, and the scan is a copy of it. A reliable copy has the same evidential weight as the original, subject to the court’s assessment. It remains prudent to keep the paper original.
- Is a simple electronic signature valid?
- Yes. Its legal effect cannot be denied solely because it is not qualified. Its reliability is not presumed, however: if it is challenged, it will have to be shown that the process meets Articles 1366 and 1367 of the French Civil Code.
- What is the risk of a scanned signature in a dispute?
- If the other party denies having signed, the party relying on the contract must prove consent. Without an identification process, that proof rests on correspondence and performance of the contract. The court decides, and the contract may not be upheld.
- Can you insert an image of your signature into a PDF?
- Nothing prohibits it in general, and it is common practice for low-stakes documents. It is not a reliable identification process. For an important contract, an electronic signature service provides stronger evidence.
This article provides general information as of its last update. It does not constitute legal advice and does not replace your counsel’s analysis of a specific situation.
Further reading
See how a signature works in Docform
A demo of the signing journey, the evidence file and the contract repository, with its limits and based on your use cases.